Recruitment Agency Now

Navigation

Loading...
You are here:  Home  >  News  >  Current Article

All female shortlists deemed unlawful

July 31, 2014  /   No Comments

Jo Faragher

An attempt by business secretary Vince Cable to bring in all-female shortlists for top executive roles has been ruled unlawful by the Equalities and Human Rights Commission (EHRC).

He had asked the EHRC to advise him on the legality of excluding men when drawing up roles in FTSE-listed companies, as part of an effort to get more women on boards.

However, Laura Carstensen, an EHRC commissioner, has issued new guidance which makes it clear that using women-only shortlists is unlawful under equality law.

The guidance states that it would constitute “unlawful sex discrimination to select a person for a role because of their gender”.

It adds: “The law does not permit positive discrimination when making an appointment or a promotion. However, the law provides scope for companies to address any disadvantage or disproportionately low participation on boards by enabling or encouraging applications from a particular gender, provided selection is made on merit.”

The push for all-female shortlists came after the publication of a report earlier this year by Charlotte Sweeney, a former head of diversity at banks HSBC and Nomura. She had suggested putting at least one woman on the shortlist for all board positions. 

According to the EHRC, the only way positive action like this would be permitted would be if people of one gender are under-represented in that sector or company – and then the measures adopted must pursue a “legitimate aim” of addressing the cause of the under-representation.

The Insitute of Directors has already rejected the idea of all-women shortlists, saying it would be better to help boards appoint more women through measures such as aspirational targets, wider advertising and mentoring or shadowing programmes.

 

    Print       Email
  • Published: 3 years ago on July 31, 2014
  • Last Modified: July 30, 2014 @ 5:18 am
  • Filed Under: News, Weekly Bulletin

RA Now TV

RA Now 2016 Preview

RA Now 2016 Preview

View all →

Your Voice

  • Oct 12
    Via @umbrella_co_uk on Twitter  Three things contractors could find in the Autumn Budget 2017.  #UmbrellaBudget http://ow.ly/fMuR30fz9MC  Read More
  • Sep 28
    Via @UndercoverRec on Twitter  How can employers avoid bias in the recruitment process?  http://ow.ly/wDvU30ftE2l Read More
  • Sep 14
    Via @iMariaJohnsen on Twitter Talent Acquisition in the Digital Marketing Sector http://ow.ly/s5An30f8Dvg Read More
  • Aug 24
    Via @TheRecNetwork1 on Twitter  Struggling to find and retain talent in your business? We've written a great guide to help you tackle this issue! http://ow.ly/kC4d30eBerg Read More

RSS News

Archive